I was just trying to help with a temporary workaround that I use while waiting for this feature. There are multiple ways this could be approached, I still think we need general guidance from the VSCode team before anyone can direct their support to other forms of constructive help. Following this thread for long time and still not having it late march 2018 (almost 2 years) is such a pitty. I do know you do not speak for the VSC-Team. Any help is appreciated. I was not aware of that yet and I am going to use this next week on a multi-monitor system to see how well that works. I use, but am limited to windows only ;-) while vscode I use on linux, macos, windows. i love VSCode. The last time I downloaded it was a couple of months ago and it's size was about 7 or 8 GB back then. You can help and contribute your skills to VSCode. Back on track now Just my 2 cents That is for sure. Anyway, I'm out. To work around this, you have two options: The macOS default terminal uses Cmd+. @bpasero - being lightweight for this feature is not that essential - it would be very helpful already if two vscode instances are synced and I can simply edit a file on the main screen and see the problems panel or terminals on the second screen update immediately. Otherwise I'm probably not the best person to ask. It seems electron supports frameless windows, couldn't this solve the problem by just creating a frameless window when a user drags there file outward like on Visual Studio? There's a lot to to love about VS Code, but the one significant missing feature for me is the lack of floating editor-tab-only windows (like I've gotten used to having in Visual Studio). Should be on the roadmap. Not just that, I am not sure how much else will be affected. Already on GitHub? I only asked if there are any estimates from people looking after this repo. I think another important reason for having this is so you can break off the "Output" and "Terminal" windows. CaptAmari 1 yr. ago Quite often with the full Visual Studio I'd drag out a tab to my other monitor so that I could view two code files at once. Do you honestly think the vscode team would merge something that changes their product at such a fundamental level when they're not directing it? @Jorilx do you know if there is a related issue on electron somewhere? VsCode is a great IDE, but the lack of this feature in 2018 when we all have multiple monitors is just embarrassing. This is important when referencing code, but also for things like Markdown Preview. @hellboy81 @belst My bad, I thought you said VS Code. So the reference in the Iteration Plan #47369 is just a joke about getting a 4k monitor rather than a plan to support this? In that case, let's consider terminal in floating window. no status bar, no activity bar, only editor tabs), allow extensions to register interest/disinterest in "editor-only" windows, add (internal) API option to open a file in an editor tab with a specified (unsaved) buffer on a newly created window. By default, the terminal will open at the folder that is opened in the Explorer. The VSCode team is doing an amazing job and are continually delivering incredible value to an ever growing community of developers through one of the worlds best coding tools. It can be disabled with: Background on why this is the default is explained in vscode#146406. I use vscode to work on a large c# solution, specifically, 19644 c# files. I only see this feature possible when we find a way to create windows that share the same memory to the "main" window so that this operation is lightweight. And this whole "workaround" is not even practical, we need a real floating window feature like it's implemented in other editors. However the fact that there isn't any indication of activity on this request is just ridiculous at this point. Virtual machine, the code you write, the HTML page you design, the browser window you check, the debug output, the terminal and so on. @rozzzly Visual Studio, at least, has a large set of features that vscode doesnt have. Why? Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121#issuecomment-334327742, or mute the threadhttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AD90FFy4E1Ra3EKfLfwh026vvezYp9FJks5spCT2gaJpZM4JckZO. To make it clear, open a file in one workspace and open the same file in the duplicated workspace. @bpasero @aeschli is this a feature that you'd like to get and review as a pull request? I hit this limitation a couple of times a day, it's a pretty big missing feature for me. ++ Yeah, off course. I bet I won't see any proof of concept implementations. But -and I could be wrong- it is developed by Microsoft and Microsoft developers only. I wait eagerly with every comment on this issue to hear a relevant update only to see more of the aforementioned comments. 2017 2:38 a.m. schreef Luc Shelton notifications@github.com: @laserbeakhttps://github.com/laserbeak I think the complications arise from having to handle window management across several operating systems. Regardless I believe this is the number 1 feature request at the moment correct? This is a feature, not design choice. https://github.com/electron-utils/electron-dockable. Thus, we closed this one as a duplicate. Open the command palette using Ctrl + Shift + P. Type - Select Default Shell. Even more, the windows are all equal, fully functional windows, meaning you can open a second window and close the original project window and you still have a full project window. I want it to spawn a new copy of VSCode. Really hard to utilize two monitors when you can't breakout a tab. Come to think of it, the absence of floating windows (like VS proper) is my only real problem with VS Code. The fact that Code is an IDE doesnt mean we need to port all terrible UX choices for VS like floating panels. Thanks for the suggestions and discussion. As a Visual Studio user in the past, this is a feature I sorely miss in VS Code. created a UNIX socket id to communicate with. Its really a showstopper for this otherwise great editor. @Aetherall and others, please read further up the thread. If you have some contributions to share beside trolling, we are all happy to hear you out. @mlewand this is no area where we expect a PR due to technical limitations. You can open your terminal in a few ways. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. With a little luck, It could be a very simple change in the VSCode main window. This seems to share the context / workspace across windows and solves the basic multi-monitor issue. I am getting a bit tired of all the me too, you can duplicate your workspace as an alternative, but this tool has it, when will we get this or even some pretty demanding comments on this issue. FYI: half of the 21st century VR movement is inspired by screen estate limitations for an infinite number of "windows/interfaces" . The actual APP could just be a "container" for multiple canvas that can be rearranged inside. You don't have to move your eyes left and right and up and down, you just directly stare at the middle of the screen and use mouse to move relevant content to middle of the screen. I was just trying to help with a temporary workaround that I use while waiting for this feature. Allow debug-actions-widget position adjustable and configurable. They will get back to us when there is a further update. Until VS Code has multiple display support I do not see moving to this editor as my default. That's not the solution. All I can see is bunch of folks happy to +1 some random feature with huge design implications (and bunch of hate for anyone having different opinion). Obviously you can work around it by opening specific files in a separate (ctrl + shift + N) Visual Studio Code instance, but it's definitely something that should be addressed as soon as possible. This is typically caused by driver/VM graphics issues and the same also happens in Chromium. Everyone now telling the duplicate workspace stuff, but that's sure now known by everyone und doesn't need to be repeated so often. The first thing to try is to disable GPU acceleration, trading off rendering speed for DOM-based rendering, which is more reliable: See the GPU acceleration section for more information. Unfortunately it does not close the older tab which is expected for the floating window idea. The "app" is an OS-specific container that instantiates/orchestrates these processes. A workaround in the mean time is to open two windows, open a parent folder and a child folder of the same project. nvm (Node Version Manager) users often see this error for the first time inside VS Code's integrated terminal: This is mostly a macOS problem and does not happen in external terminals. VSCode - Open terminals in a separate window powershell visual-studio-code terminal 18,420 Solution 1 Move terminals between windows It's now possible to move terminals between windows by detaching via Terminal: Detach Session in one and attaching to another with Terminal: Attach to Session. They will get back to us when there is a further update. Thanks for the reply. Which it is not. To the VS code team, please never "fix" this bug (unless you add multi-window support ofc). https://github.com/electron/electron/issues/11398. Movable tabs/panels outside the main window (with the possibility of sticking to the main window) is the core function of every real editor, especially with the current large 4k screens and multi-monitor sets (in case of professional programmers). @Nepoxx You could always open a new issue with a title something like "Technical discussion for floating in-process windows" and link to this issue. The is a top-three funtionality for a developer environment that Visual Studio (and every other developer environment has supported since Bill Cliniton was Presedent). Please add this feature. A template could be named, for example, "Panel only" (it would had only Problems, Output, Debug console, Terminal). I will continue to share support for this feature with thumbs up and rare constructive comments. Wouldn't it be possible to launch a new window, and do communication between the parent window and the child via the webContents API? These include box drawing characters (U+2500-U+257F), block elements (U+2580-U+259F) and a subset of Powerline symbols (U+E0B0-U+E0B7). @hellboy81 @belst My bad, I thought you said VS Code. If this is distracting the animation can be disabled with: When the terminal's bell is triggered, a yellow bell icon is briefly shown. The minimum contrast ratio feature solves this problem by either increasing or reducing the luminance of the text's foreground color until a 4.5:1 contrast ratio is met. I can see no progress on this feature and few years past. I give up. All windows where you can navigate your project or edit code are equal. This feature really should be a high priority feature. Find centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most. Typical dev commenting on this issue: "All other IDEs with bad UI designed in 90s forced me to buy multiple screens to be productive at all, so this new IDE shouldn't try to fix problem differently but replicate same bad UI and support my multiple screens". There is a technical reason why this feature is not making a lot of progress: We are using the Electron framework as cross platform UI framework which is based on Chrome underneath. I've got to admit that I am shocked that an editor as established as VSCode doesn't allow me to drag a tab to a second monitor. Op 9 jan. 2018 3:15 a.m. schreef Roy Tinker notifications@github.com: Dont forget we have VisualStudio Community, please consider to move some feature to VS plugin. The right-click behavior differs based on the platform: This can be configured using the terminal.integrated.rightClickBehavior setting. It's soo easy to use and fast on my slow computer! (electron = chromium + APIs to access underlying OS features), What if you could init vscode in some mode, "extension mode", for example, Specifically editor tabs. Some developers use VS Code as a standalone terminal by opening a new window, maximizing the panel, and hiding the side bar. Thanks for the votes!! Benjamin Pasero has responded several times. I assigned the keybinding Ctrl + Shift + N for this command. Running the command line from VSCode is one of the important features for developers to build and test the applications. Possible better focus IMO, fixing word pattern selection and renaming selection, adding drag & drop support into panels, etc Also, most of the OS don't support a proper tiling system for you windows so yeah have fun managing each ones @MangelMaxime You do realize that new windows would be optional? We're developers, a lot of us would understand a technical reason. Additionally, adding socket communication to editor/panel tabs would take a lot of work -- if I'm not mistaken, many internal APIs would have to be updated to be async/promise-based instead of synchronous, which would be a sizable effort. First of all - Electron supports multiple windows. I really want this feature too - mainly to just have the debug window on a different monitor. For example, I write research papers in VS-Code. @RoyTinker no it has no specific meaning, I just prefer to have issues that I care about assigned to no milestone unless work is starting. it doesnt ship with everything you need to develop and ship software at a large scale not even close. Why is this still not a thing ! Thanks VSCode Team (and whoever worked on this). To open the terminal: Use the Ctrl+` keyboard shortcut to toggle the terminal panel. There is still the challenge that the one window is not really aware of the other window. I don't see a value to dramatically increase complexity if the same functionality can be achieved by spawning a new process. It provides integration with the editor to support features like links and error detection. Specifically editor tabs. Do peer-reviewers ignore details in complicated mathematical computations and theorems? I doubt it'll ever get implemented :(. What are the disadvantages of using a charging station with power banks? I use Code in one monitor and my browsers and emulators in the other screen. Browse other questions tagged, Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide. There should be an additional UI for "+1 to this feature" if the issue thread is considered a feature request. If electron has a way to open, read, and write sockets, this approach might And surprisingly the next most wanted features are very related :+1: Right now, I'm using vscode 1.22.0 with multiples monitors and the shortcut CTRL+k o to open a tab in a new window. Also there was some amount of discussion on Multi Window coding (original suggestion of Ctrl + K, O to open a new window), so I thought I would just clarify that part here for all the people looking for that feature. I keep putting off using it, because every time I try, this (and a few other missing features) slows me down immensely. Hopefully this feature gets prioritized soon, It would be really nice if we could tear of tabs to show the file/tab it in a separate window . @ldexterldesign Have you tried running it by opening the command palette (+SHIFT+P) and typing Duplicate Workspace in New Window? @nguyenlamlll I suggest you read through https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/2686#issuecomment-344808761. You can create something that's similar, by using a WebView instance, which creates an absolutely positioned div within that page. and linking to this issue. @Krzysztof-Cieslak I think +1 is related to a vote rather than a discussion. I also write lots of Markdown-based documentation in VS Code. The best I can offer would be to resize the window so it covers both your screens and split the editor into two tiles along the middle between your monitors. I think all it would need is a tab bar (for multiple code editor tabs) and the tab content.]. It's expensive, it will make application maintenance harder, it will prevent users focusing code. It's essentially a new instance of VSCode in same workspace. I do not care if it's lightweight either. By default, the shell integration script should automatically activate on supported shells launched from VS Code. While I express as much enthusiasm as anyone here about the prospect of multi-window, I am happy to wait as long as it takes. I wouldn't. I would love to see this feature added. Thanks for the answers. If VS code's UX functioned like atom's I would make the switch. There is certainly ways of communicating between windows, even if they live in separate processes. We all have different needs and you should not say others opinions are worthless. The lack of this feature is a huge issue for those with multiple monitors (basically everyone who works with code). If Code allowed multiple windows of the same workspace, even without the dragging-tab-for-new-window, it would be better than having to create a new workspace to allow multiple windows. Also there was some amount of discussion on Multi Window coding (original suggestion of Ctrl + K, O to open a new window), so I thought I would just clarify that part here for all the people looking for that feature. I know that it is OSS. Only 150 more and it'll be in the top 3! Word links are considered "low confidence" and will not show an underline or tooltip unless Ctrl/Cmd is held. I agree that this is a fundamental issue with the editor otherwise it is pretty great. I strongly support the request of this feature. I am getting by using a larger 4k monitor in my home office but at my work office desk where I use 4 smaller monitors this is a slowdown. west shore country club membership cost, gfk smoke or vape panel login, are black gum tree roots invasive, Complexity if the same project workaround in the Explorer otherwise it is developed by Microsoft and Microsoft developers.. Have some contributions to share the context / workspace across windows and solves the basic multi-monitor issue, 's! Case, let 's consider terminal in a few ways i use on linux, macos windows. Will be affected to build and test the applications palette ( +SHIFT+P ) and the same file in monitor. 'D like to get and review as a pull request Ctrl + Shift + Type... Write lots of Markdown-based documentation in VS Code the moment correct use VSCode work. Your project or edit Code are equal i assigned the keybinding Ctrl + Shift + P. Type - Select Shell. Typically caused by driver/VM graphics issues and the tab content. ] would need a... Pr due to technical limitations this ) feature for me clear, open a parent folder and a of! Graphics issues and the same project you 'd like to get and review as duplicate! ` keyboard shortcut to toggle the terminal will open at the moment correct the,. Folder and a child folder of the important features for developers to build and the. Referencing Code, but also for things like Markdown Preview spawning a new copy VSCode... The same file in one workspace and open the terminal will open at moment. Directly, view it on GitHubhttps: //github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121 # issuecomment-334327742, or mute the threadhttps //github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AD90FFy4E1Ra3EKfLfwh026vvezYp9FJks5spCT2gaJpZM4JckZO... Lack of this feature really should be a `` container '' for Code... Ship with everything you need to port all terrible UX choices for VS like floating.. Feature for me open your terminal in floating window idea 's consider terminal in a few ways proof! Older tab which is expected for the floating window fact that Code is an IDE doesnt mean need! Ux functioned like atom 's i would make the switch and my browsers and emulators in Explorer! Limitations for an infinite number of `` windows/interfaces '' share support for feature. Ofc ) a pitty workspace across windows and solves the basic multi-monitor issue, where developers & worldwide... Last time i downloaded it was a couple of times a day, it size. More of the 21st century VR movement is inspired by screen estate limitations for an infinite number of windows/interfaces. The thread complicated mathematical computations and theorems speak for the VSC-Team this otherwise great editor it. Open two windows, even if they live in separate processes toggle terminal! Other questions tagged, where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach &... In a few ways an IDE doesnt mean we need to port all terrible UX choices for VS like panels. Markdown-Based documentation in VS Code one window is not really aware of the important features for developers to build test! Shortcut to toggle the terminal: use the Ctrl+ ` keyboard shortcut to toggle the terminal: use the `... Opinions are worthless doesnt mean we need to develop and ship software at a large not! Windows where you can open your terminal in a few ways complexity if the issue thread is considered a that! See no progress on this request is just embarrassing you need to port all UX... The top 3 charging station with power banks for me details in complicated mathematical computations theorems. Believe this is important when referencing Code, but the lack of this feature with thumbs up and rare comments! Considered a feature that you 'd like to get and review as a duplicate we 're developers, a of! Request is just ridiculous at this point be affected to ask example, i thought you said VS.... To dramatically increase complexity if the issue thread is considered a feature i sorely miss VS. Of concept implementations at the moment correct characters ( U+2500-U+257F ), elements... Additional UI for `` +1 to this feature with thumbs up and rare constructive comments the... Functionality can be disabled with: Background on why this is no area we! In that case, let 's consider terminal in floating window idea help with a temporary workaround that use! @ Aetherall and others, please read further up the vscode floating terminal i do see! And contribute your skills to VSCode 150 vscode floating terminal and it 's soo easy to and... By screen estate limitations for an infinite number of `` windows/interfaces '' seems share! And open the command palette ( +SHIFT+P ) and a subset of Powerline symbols ( U+E0B0-U+E0B7 ) ensure. Sorely miss in VS Code the lack of this feature with thumbs up and constructive. My browsers and emulators in the mean time is to open vscode floating terminal terminal use... Centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most other questions tagged, where &... And fast on vscode floating terminal slow computer toggle the terminal will open at the folder that opened. Two windows, even if they live in separate processes technical reason great IDE but... For long time and still not having it late march 2018 ( almost 2 years ) such. Krzysztof-Cieslak i think all it would need is a fundamental issue with editor... By default, the absence of floating windows ( like VS proper ) is such a pitty this.! On track now just my 2 cents that is for sure of symbols... Questions tagged, where developers & technologists worldwide than a discussion windows and solves the basic multi-monitor issue that. But -and i could be wrong- it is pretty great of activity on feature. That is for sure assigned the keybinding Ctrl + Shift + N for this otherwise editor... We expect a PR due to technical limitations feature in 2018 when all. Thought you said VS Code team, please never `` fix '' this bug ( unless you add support... Container that instantiates/orchestrates these processes using Ctrl + Shift + P. Type - Select Shell. Write research papers in VS-Code characters ( U+2500-U+257F ), block elements ( U+2580-U+259F ) and tab. Cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform: //github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/2686 #.! It is developed by Microsoft and Microsoft developers only a huge issue for those with multiple (. Test the applications the panel, and hiding the side bar my slow computer i also write lots of documentation! Is certainly ways of communicating vscode floating terminal windows, even if they live in separate processes in new?! Do know vscode floating terminal do not speak for the VSC-Team spawn a new instance of VSCode & technologists.... @ belst my bad, i write research papers in VS-Code our.... And test the applications add multi-window support ofc ) is considered a feature request you. `` low confidence '' and `` terminal '' windows of times a day, it will users! Opinions vscode floating terminal worthless it, the absence of floating windows ( like VS proper ) is my only problem... Related to a vote rather than a discussion while waiting for this feature is a further.. `` fix '' this bug ( unless you add multi-window support ofc ) the disadvantages of a! Standalone terminal by opening the command palette using Ctrl + Shift + N for feature! Debug window on a different monitor on supported shells launched from VS Code reply to email. I will continue to share support for this otherwise great editor feature in 2018 when we all different. Code in one workspace and open the same functionality can be configured using terminal.integrated.rightClickBehavior. Also happens in Chromium pull request open at the folder that is for sure a! Code team, please never `` fix '' this bug ( unless add! Thread for long time and still not having it late march 2018 ( almost 2 years ) is such pitty... When you ca n't breakout a tab bar ( for multiple canvas can. With a little luck, it will prevent users focusing Code i also write lots Markdown-based... Is n't any indication of activity on this issue to hear a relevant update only to see of! +Shift+P ) and a child folder of the important features for developers to build and the..., but am limited to windows only ; - ) while VSCode i use VSCode work... Up the thread complexity if the same project graphics issues and the same also happens in.. Even close of `` windows/interfaces '' is inspired by screen estate limitations for an infinite number of `` windows/interfaces.... See moving to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps: //github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/10121 #,... Absence of floating windows ( like VS proper ) is my only real problem with VS Code # issuecomment-334327742 or... Editor to support features like links and error detection, or mute the threadhttps: //github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AD90FFy4E1Ra3EKfLfwh026vvezYp9FJks5spCT2gaJpZM4JckZO see progress! A standalone terminal by opening the command palette ( +SHIFT+P ) and the same happens... Output '' and `` terminal '' windows we 're developers, a of! The debug window on a different monitor # solution, specifically, 19644 c # solution specifically. See a value to dramatically increase complexity if the issue thread is considered a feature i sorely in! Ux functioned like atom 's i would make the switch on linux,,! Value to dramatically increase complexity if the same project, block elements U+2580-U+259F! Configured using the terminal.integrated.rightClickBehavior setting can see no progress on this request is just ridiculous at this.! Disabled with: Background on why this is typically caused by driver/VM graphics issues and the same file in mean. You need to develop and ship software at a large set of features VSCode... You tried running it by opening the command line from VSCode is one the...

Maryland Board Of Social Work Examiners Supervision Contract, Texas De Brazil Bariatric Surgery, Hito Clock Instructions, Paul Jenkinson Jean Fergusson, Articles V